Cases solved by tool marks

Is the CSI effect real? Some legal and criminal experts have opined that the popularity of forensic TV shows, particularly the CSI franchise, has had a detrimental effect on the justice system. Specifically, they complain that juries have come to expect forensic evidence in every case and are less likely to convict without it.

In real life, forensic sciences are a complement to quality police work, but also have an undeniable place in modern criminal investigation. In fact, these murders have gone cold for years, even decades, until recent forensic developments allowed police to finally catch the killer.

In the early 90s, the body of a young woman was found dumped in the Arizona Canal running through Phoenix. Ten months later, another victim was dumped in the same place. The cases went cold until when the police got a new lead courtesy of forensic genealogist Colleen Fitzpatrick. According to her, there are thousands of these databases—some of them organized by companies or professionals, but most by genealogy enthusiasts who post their DNA profiles in the hopes of finding distant relatives.

Since the killer was most likely a man, Fitzpatrick searched only along the Y-DNA line for possible matches. Within a few weeks, the forensic genealogist tracked down a likely surname—Miller. Police looked through their list of suspects and identified Bryan Patrick Miller.

They compared his DNA to that of the suspect and got a match. Miller was arrested in and is awaiting trial. Twenty-three years ago, the dismembered body of a young man was discovered behind a gas station in Lake City, Florida.

Several items related to the murder were also present at the scene, including a blood-soaked flannel shirt, a mattress cover, bathtub safety pads, and bloody knives that were most likely the murder weapons. Despite having DNA from the killer and the victim, both remained unidentified for decades. This changed in when modern tests and an updated DNA database finally identified the victim as year-old Fred Laster.

His family confirmed that Laster disappeared in shortly before the discovery of his mutilated body. Once police knew the identity of the victim, they established a short list of suspects. On that list was Ronnie Leon Hyde, a former youth pastor who was a friend of the family.

One of the most modern, most sensitive forensic tools helped solve the cold case of a teenager found bludgeoned to death by the side of the Provo River in Utah in The victim was year-old Krystal Beslanowitch.

Next to her, police found cartographer ros github murder weapon—a blood-stained rock.Sometimes, crimes are easy to solve. However, careful criminals sometimes leave little to no evidence, making the investigation of the scene or surrounding areas crucial.

Sometimes, all it takes is one tiny piece of evidence that would have been incredibly easy to overlook to nab the bad guy.

In the summer ofthe body of a young woman was found partially submerged in a large drum of water in the small town of Wood River, Illinois. Her name was Karla Brown, and she had been brutally beaten, raped, and murdered. Although the crime appeared to be rushed and poorly planned, there seemed to be no evidence pointing toward a suspect.

Even this breakthrough was useless without a set of teeth for comparison, though. Since even the police had only recently discovered this detail, it was all but impossible for an innocent member of the public to know about it.

After they matched, Prante was convicted of murder and sentenced to 75 years in prison. By all accounts, Charlotte Grabbe was not in the best of marriages. She and her husband, Fred, fought constantly for 23 years, even divorcing and remarrying a short time later. Fred was an abusive husband and father so prone to fits of violence that Charlotte left a letter in her safe-deposit box stating that she was afraid her husband was going to kill her.

Inshe disappearednever to be found. Despite not having a body, authorities suspected murder, and they had their sights trained on Fred.

Cases Where DNA Revealed that Bite Mark Analysis Led to Wrongful Arrests and Convictions

Eventually, his former girlfriend came forward to claim that Charlotte had been strangled by her husband, who had burned the body by a tree near the Wabash River. What no one knew was that he was also a serial rapistterrorizing the women of his town for 13 of those years.

All they knew was that Lafayette and a neighboring town had been struck by a series of unsolved rapes that all appeared to have been committed by the same man.

Maddeningly, he never left any physical evidence and always covered his face with a ski mask, leaving him unidentifiable. Comeaux might have gotten away with his crimes or even committed countless more had he not made one simple mistake.

Faced with that damning piece of evidence, he first pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity but later entered a simple guilty plea. He was given three life sentences. The abduction of Vicki Lynne Hoskinson gripped the Tucson area in the mids. The eight-year-old girl had left her house on her bike one day, meaning to mail a birthday card for her aunt, and was never seen again.Tools are often used by criminals to force entry to premises and can leave behind evidence for the forensic scientist to find.

Two tools of the same kind and made by the same manufacturer may look the same, but through use each tool can acquire differences. It is these differences that make them unique.

Bite Mark Evidence Used to Convict Pennsylvania Man of Rape Is Called into Question

Forensic Scientists are able to help the courts convict criminals by matching the marks on tools to those found at crime scenes. The examination of tool marks, as with other physical evidence, is based on two characteristics - class characteristics and individual characteristics.

Class characteristics are those characteristics that are common to a group of objects. For example, a hammer has a distinctive shape and typical size. Individual characteristics are those characteristics which are unique to a given object.

They are generally as a result of wear and tear or may be caused by isolated incidents during manufacture. For example, you buy a new pair of shoes and as you wear the shoes, over time you will get scratches and gouges on the soles.

These marks are unique to your shoes. Caused by the interaction of two objects, tool mark impressions are distinguished in a variety of ways:. The Scene Examiner will examine and photograph the tool marks in situ. If appropriate, the Scene Examiner will remove the object with the marks and take it to the lab for further analysis. If this is not possible they will make a cast of the marks, generally using a silicone rubber.

A tool may be recovered that is suspected to have caused the damage and this will also be taken to the lab for further analysis. The Forensic Scientist will make test marks using the suspect implement. The test mark and the mark recovered from the crime scene will then be compared. The Forensic Scientist will examine and compare the striation patterns using the comparison microscope. By comparing and matching the striations the scientist can prove whether the tool is responsible for the impression.

Tools can also have trace evidence, such as paint flakes adhering or, in the case of a human victim, blood or other body fluids.

Cookies on our website

This evidence greatly assists in the investigation of a crime. Characteristics The examination of tool marks, as with other physical evidence, is based on two characteristics - class characteristics and individual characteristics. A good example is a crow bar being used to force open a window and a subsequent impression is left in the softer surface of the wood. The Forensic Scientist will examine the marks and may be able to identify what type and size of tool caused the damage.

Dynamic marks are made when a tool slides or scratches across a surface. Think of a key being dragged along the side of a car; such an instrument leaves behind a pattern of lines or striations in the metal of the car. The pattern of striations may be enough for the examiner to identify a match with the tool belonging to a suspect.

Cutting marks are a result of pressure being applied at both sides of an object and are often associated with scissors, wire cutters or shears. When used these tools can leave behind marks and striations along the cut edges of the material.

Multi-stroke marks are caused by repetitive action, such as a saw moving back and forth. Examination The Scene Examiner will examine and photograph the tool marks in situ.I know my site is all about Firearms Identification but did you know that Firearms Identification is actually a form of Tool Mark Identification? The barrel of a firearm is a tool that leaves a tool mark on bullets. Anytime two objects come together there is the potential for the softer of the two items to be marked in some way.

Tool marks are very common in any crime where forced entry is involved.

cases solved by tool marks

Tools commonly used are screwdrivers, pry bars, hammers, and bolt cutters. All have the potential to leave a unique "tool mark" in much the same way a firearm leaves its mark on ammunition components.

The steering column Figure 1. This was done to reach the ignition and to disable the steering wheel lock. Figure 1. Steering Column. A suspect located near the vehicle was found to have a screwdriver Figure 2.

Figure 2. The investigating officer submitted the steering column along with the screwdriver to see if the screwdriver might have been used to pry open the steering column. The steering column was examined and an area of striated tool marks was found on a small internal part Figure 3.

Figure 3. Close-up of tool mark upper right box. The questioned tool mark was cast using a dental rubber casting medium Figure 4.

This was done so the tool mark could be examined microscopically It's tough to get a steering column under the microscope! Figure 4. Cast tool mark. Standards were then made with the questioned screwdriver.

The tip of the screwdriver was pulled across soft sheet lead at various angles and in different directions. The "test" tool marks were cast in the same method used to cast the questioned tool mark on the steering column Figure 5. Figure 5.Forensic Dentistry or forensic odontology is the proper handling, examination and evaluation of dental evidence.

It is the application of dental knowledge to assist in the investigation process for law agencies. Forensic dentists can use their vast knowledge to identify human remains as well as determine age, gender, race, occupation, previous dental history and socioeconomic status.

Identification is done by comparing ante mortem dental records to the post mortem records through the use of x-rays. Another type of evidence is bite mark analysis, wherein a dentist will make a cast of the suspects teeth and compare them to bite marks found on a victim or at the scene of a crime. Wayne Boden, a Canadian serial killer was convicted for several murders based on bite mark evidence on his last victim. Enough for a jury to find him guilty. In the event of human skeletal remains being found…would a medical examiner request a missing persons dental records before determining gender of the remains?

Enter your email address to subscribe to this news blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.News Skepticism around bite mark analysis has mounted in recent years in part because of the growing number of wrongful convictions attributable to bite mark evidence. Kunco was sentenced to 45 to 90 years in prison. On the night of December 17,Kunco had a solid alibi: he was at home in bed with his girlfriend and their infant child.

According to the two forensic dentists, the use of an ultraviolet light was able to help them examine marks purportedly left on the victim by the perpetrator months prior. The victim never saw the perpetrator during the course of the attack. In addition to being blindfolded, she also suffered from partial physical blindness. Consequently, during the investigation, the victim was asked to make a voice identification of the perpetrator, a highly unreliable method to secure an identification.

Based on that combined evidence, Kunco was found guilty. Inthe Innocence Project was successful in obtaining DNA testing of probative crime scene evidence. Those results excluded Kunco as the source of the DNA. Kunco was the biter. On Monday, one of those experts, Dr. Two other forensic dentists, including the sitting president of the ABFO, Adam Freeman, also testified as witnesses on behalf of Kunco that recent research confirms assertions made by the National Academy of Sciences inthat bite mark analysis is not a legitimate forensic tool and should not be used in criminal investigation.

Based on this new evidence, the Innocence Project has petitioned the court to vacate Mr. Help us advocate for the innocent by sharing the latest news from the Innocence Project. Join our mailing list. All I can say is, I am so happy he is coming home! Denton, a mother and grandmother, is free at last," said Chris Fabricant, director of strategic litigation at the Innocence Project.

Brandon Moon spent 17 years wrongfully convicted. A life-long technician, he now works at a biotech company repairing COVID test to help fight the pandemic. Press Release. Special Features. Share this story Help us advocate for the innocent by sharing the latest news from the Innocence Project. Leave a reply. Jenn Snyder says:. Olga Kunco says:.

Cookies on our website

Share Facebook Twitter Linkedin. Featured news. Load More Articles Loading Press "Enter" or click on the arrow to show results. Filter Cases. Any Year Any Year Years All A witness or suspect may decide to talk, or people might be more forthcoming about details after time has passed.

The good thing is that families can reach better closure about what has happened, even though this can mean re-living many painful details at a trial or hearing.

cases solved by tool marks

Convictions can result, and prison sentences be given, and, as in the case of three cold cases included on this list, inmates already in prison can receive much longer sentences. Take a look at our list of 10 solved cold cases below. A determined cop who was the original investigator into the murder of Krystal Beslanowitch 18 years ago in Utah helped bring resolution to this case.

Beslanowitch was 17 years old when she died from a crushing blow to the skull. A prostitute, her body was found in along the Provo River.

cases solved by tool marks

Leads at the time only led to dead-ends, but investigators finally got somewhere inwhen new forensic technologiestaking a full day, were used to extract touch DNA from the granite rock that crushed her skull. In fact, a tool called a forensic vacuum allowed for the DNA extraction. Simpson, now 46, was arrested in Florida in September of this year. An alert fisherman may have helped solve this cold case, which has been unresolved since In that year, Sherri Miller and Pam Jackson, both 17, disappeared while driving on rural roads to a party at a gravel pit in a Studebaker Lark.

NPR reports that the vehicle was removed from the creek the following day, and skeletal remains, thought to be of the two girls, were found inside. Indeed, as NPR reports, the creek was less than half a mile from the gravel pit that the girls were headed to and the license plate and a hubcap from the vehicle, although badly decomposed, matched the vehicle the girls were driving.

Even though it looks like this year-old cold case may be solved, it might never be known what happened to lead to the Studebaker ending up in the creek. Pamela Shelley died en route to a hospital in after she was found with a gunshot wound to the head in the Texas home that she shared with her boyfriend.

Not long before, she had split up with her husband, and moved with her two children from Arkansas to Texas into the home of Ronnie Joe Hendrick, an old family friend. Investigators initially ruled her death a suicide, but the case was re-opened seven years later at the insistence of investigator Carl Bowen, who had been on patrol and responded to the initial incident, according to the Victoria Advocate.

Bowen never felt quite right about the suicide ruling, and enough evidence was eventually gathered to indict Hendrick in October with a trial set for September A mistrial occurred, but Hendrick, instead, plead guilty to a charge of murder. He was sentenced to 22 years in prison.

It had not been quite clear what happened to Rayna Rison when, at age 16, she disappeared into be found dead a month later in an Indiana pond by a fisherman. In August, prosecutors charged Tibbs with allegedly strangling her to death following an argument about the two of them getting back together, reports the NW Times.

It was not forensic evidence, but the July testimony of a former friend, Eric Freeman, who said he saw Tibbs strangle Rison and then assisted him in disposing of her body in the pond. Sadly enough, when the death of a homeless or transient person occurs, not as much attention might be given to solving the crime. Petersburg, Fla.

Screams were heard about 11 p. DNA evidence was collected at the scene, but progress had never been made until this year when it was linked to Raymond Samuels, aged 31 as of this writing November, He has been in prison since in Ohio for attempted murder and kidnapping and will be extradited to Florida.

According to investigators, it was DNA that was imperative to solving this crime, and, as a result, Samuels now faces first-degree murder charges.

Detectives brought up three first-degree murder charges against Donna Perry, 61, at the end of October for allegedly killing three prostitutes in in Spokane, Wash. Perry, who was actually Douglas Perry prior to a sex change, was arrested in on federal charges of possession of illegal firearms. The investigation into the deaths of the three women had been re-opened in with DNA evidence submitted in and sent through a federal database, which eventually matched to Perry.

She has been moved from prison in Texas to Spokane to face charges. Fifty-five years after 7-year-old Maria Ridulph was taken from the streets of Sycamore, Ill. McCullough had been one of about potential suspects, but seemed to have a rock-solid alibi at the time of the murder. His mother had backed up his whereabouts. However, with her admission about her alibi, police reinvestigated McCullough, who was sentenced to life in prison in for the crime. The strangulation death of Patricia Beard in her studio apartment back in in Denver became the th rape or murder to be solved by Denver Cold Case Team in July of this year.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *